Lisa Krenz was born and raised in Orange County, CA. She attended college at Concordia University in Irvine, CA where she was involved in Student Leadership, Handbells, Theater, Choir, campus spiritual life, and going to class. She graduated in 2010 with a Liberal Arts degree (with a Lutheran teaching certification) and went on to student teach in Orange County. During this time, she was also the youth director at her home church (Redeemer Lutheran in Huntington Beach). In July 2011, she packed up and moved out to Independence, KS where she accepted a call as a middle school teacher at Zion Lutheran School.
At St. Paul's Oktoberfest in October 2011, she met Andy Krenz. They were married in May 2014 and she moved to South Coffeyville, OK. A year later, Lisa resigned from her call at Zion and started a baking business out of her home. A year later, she also took the job of secretary at St. Paul's. In October 2016, their son Nathaniel James Krenz was born and he quickly became the junior secretary at St. Paul's.